After some tallying and cross-checking with votes done on TPWW itself, ended up with 26 total votes for the 2017 Sheety's. For some comparison, last year had 15 votes total.
Without further ado, here are the winner's of TPWW's 2017 Sheetys Awards:
Best Rasslin Company of the Year
WWE (12 votes, runner-up: NJPW - 7 votes)
Worst Rasslin Company of the Year
TNA/Impact/GFW/Impact (23 votes, runner-up: GFW - 2 votes)
Best Rassler of the Year
AJ Styles (16 votes, runner-up: Braun Strowman - 5 votes)
Best Woman Rassler of the Year
Asuka (12 votes, runner-up: Alexa Bliss - 8 votes)
The Completely Not Rigged But Everyone Better Vote for New Day Tag Team of the Year
Usos (15 votes, runner-up: Sheamus & Ceasro - 6 votes)
Big E Appreciation Award
Rusev (14 votes, runner-up: Elias - 5 votes)
2017 Best Wrestling Forum Poster named Shadrick
Ultra Mantis (7 votes, runner-up: Shadrick & Destor - 6 votes each)
Dumbest moment of the year
Anthem's botch of the GFW-Impact merger (17 votes, runner-up: "Bayley: This Is Your Life" - 4 votes)
Match of the Year
John Cena vs AJ Styles at Royal Rumble '17 (14 votes, runner-up: Pete Dunne vs. Tyler Bate at NXT TakeOver: Chicago & Kazuchika Okada vs Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 11 - 4 votes each)
Best Entrance Theme
"Glorious Domination" (9 votes, runner-up: "Root of All Evil" & "The Rising Sun" - 5 votes each)