Punk can talk a good game, but only had a couple of really outstanding matches. One being against DB, as others have already said, and the other being against Y2J. His match with Rock could've maybe been something special at Royal Rumble (2013), where his 434-day WWE Championship reign was ended at the hands of The Great One. Punk also had the look, but ultimately a lot of unrealized potential during his time in WWE.
Shawn, on the other hand, cut great promos, had an awesome look, and far too many outstanding matches to list. We all know he's not called Mr. WrestleMania for nothing. So, yeah... easy vote for HBK.
|